Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 15 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Rubric for Writing Project #1
Rubric for Writing Project #1
Criteria Ratings
The author sums up their position with an open or closed thesis statement (major claim) in the first couple of paragraphs.
a. Introduce and define the assigned problem/concern;
b. Illustrate and analyze the effects of the problem/concern on students, and if you like, other people who care (i.e., parents, managers, taxpayers, communities, our civilization, etc.), drawing on personal experience and observations, course readings, and/or your own research;
c. explain and exemplify the ways in which the problem can be addressed and perhaps solved, drawing on course readings, research, and your own, original ideas;
d. consider obstacles to the problem/solution and how they might be addressed;
e. recap your proposed solutions and persuade your reader of the vital importance of working towards improving and/or solving this problem for now and the future.
The author uses a clear critical— “academic”—voice to answer the entire prompt, including a-e.
The author supports ideas and assertions with specific examples, details, information, paraphrases, and quotes from at least two assigned readings and two additional sources from the Grossmont College Databases or some other reputable source (to total 4 required sources).
The author summarizes texts/explains ideas/information fully enough for readers not in our class to follow.
The author discusses complexities and does not make things seem simpler than they really are.
The author presents ideas in an order that makes sense to the readers.
The author opens with an introduction that engages readers and ends with a conclusion that completes the discussion.
The author creates comprehensive topic sentences (aka, road signs) and makes sure each paragraph is well developed and has a clear focus by addressing its topic sentence.
The author uses transitional words and phrases to connect the different parts of the paper together (within and between paragraphs).
The author proofreads carefully so that sentences are clear.
The author paraphrases skillfully so that the original meaning remains true but sentences and words are significantly different (not just a few words changed) and uses concise present tense verbs and “quotation marks” when including an author’s exact words.
The author uses their critical voice to lead into quotes and lets the reader know who the quote is from and explains how quote connects to paper (ideas).
The author has produced at least 3-5 full pages, not including the Works Cited page, and uses MLA format and style, including in-text citation.